And when has anyone been blasted into the air when AK'd.
Cedric certainly was not, so why did DD go flying into the air and over the battlements when b4 Harry had said that DD was slippng futrther and further down.
And lets face it, if DD really needed Snape then why didnt he send his Patronas for him. Tonks sent her paronas early on from outside the school, so DD could have snet his when they arrived at Hogsmeade. her certainly had the strength to lift the protections when he was flying to te castle, and he had the strength to Freeze harry.
Just a few more incponsistencies in the story IMO
As for Snape / Lily, I always thought there was more to the reason DD gave to Harry for Snape turning away from LV. he didnt lie, but he did not reveal everything about the reason.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Re: One (rather unrelated) thing ...
Date: 2005-07-25 09:12 am (UTC)Cedric certainly was not, so why did DD go flying into the air and over the battlements when b4 Harry had said that DD was slippng futrther and further down.
And lets face it, if DD really needed Snape then why didnt he send his Patronas for him. Tonks sent her paronas early on from outside the school, so DD could have snet his when they arrived at Hogsmeade. her certainly had the strength to lift the protections when he was flying to te castle, and he had the strength to Freeze harry.
Just a few more incponsistencies in the story IMO
As for Snape / Lily, I always thought there was more to the reason DD gave to Harry for Snape turning away from LV. he didnt lie, but he did not reveal everything about the reason.
Mara